Plays on YouTube · loads when you press play

12 ingredients. Tap one to see it in the video

← Recipes from creators

North American · Michelle Cottrell

Banana pudding

From the video “Old-Fashioned Banana Pudding Made From Scratch” by Michelle Cottrell. RecipesMD is not affiliated with Michelle Cottrell. Steps are in our own words. Your channel? Claim, correct or remove.

Machine-read from the video · not yet checked by a personInvolvedWeekend project
Not spicy
Total time
~60 min
est., not stated in the video: typical total for this dish from the model check; no step states a time
Serves
~5
est., not stated in the video: average of rules (1: 200 g protein foods at ~170 g per serving) and model check (8)
Cost
~$1.95*
per serving, Ontario (~8 portions assumed)save ~$6.55* vs ordering out
Difficulty
Involved
Ingredients
12

The recipe at a glance

20 steps in 12 stages. Tap one to jump there.

Ingredients

  • No pork

May contain gluten, dairy, egg

Read from the ingredient list. Check packaging if you have an allergy.

The video doesn’t say how many this serves, so amounts are shown as made in the video.

Ontario grocery estimate*

~$15.59*for the batch in the video
~$1.95*per serving

You save about ~$6.55* per serving (77% less*) than ordering it out — ~$52.41* for ~8 portions.

Order out = a typical Ontario dessert, before delivery fees, tax and tip.

5 ingredients priced from Ontario averages · 6 predicted from typical costs · not priced: bananas, nilla wafers, evaporated milk, vanilla extract, powdered sugar, cream of tartar

* Estimate, not a quote: predicted from the ingredient list: 5 line(s) priced from Ontario averages, the rest filled with typical costs for their type; the video doesn't state how many it serves, so 8 portions were assumed; restaurant comparison is a typical Ontario dessert at ~$8.50, before delivery fees, tax and tip. Prices: Ontario averages (StatCan 2026-07) + RecipesMD estimates, pro-rated, staples excluded.

  • estimated: Estimated: the video doesn't give this amount, so it's our model's best guess. Check it against the video.
  • estimated: Estimated: the video doesn't give this amount, so it's our model's best guess. Check it against the video.
  • stated: Said aloud or written on screen in the video.
  • stated: Said aloud or written on screen in the video.
  • estimated: Estimated: the video doesn't give this amount, so it's our model's best guess. Check it against the video.
  • stated: Said aloud or written on screen in the video.
  • stated: Said aloud or written on screen in the video.
  • stated: Said aloud or written on screen in the video.
  • stated: Said aloud or written on screen in the video.
  • stated: Said aloud or written on screen in the video.
  • stated: Said aloud or written on screen in the video.
  • stated: Said aloud or written on screen in the video.

stated said or written in the video · shown seen in the video · estimated our guess (3 here)

Nutrition & health

Nutrition per serving713 kcal · 36% of 2,000
NutrientAmountDaily value
Fat23 g29%
Saturated fat13 g65%
Sodium345 mg15%
Carbohydrate126 g46%
Fiber2.6 g9%
Total sugars111 gno daily value
Added sugars99 g198%
Protein6.7 g13%

Estimate from the ingredient list — not dietary advice. % Daily Value uses FDA reference amounts; 5% or less is low, 20% or more is high. Added sugars are counted from sweeteners and sweet sauces in the list.

Health indexTreat
  • Starting point60
  • Protein+5 of 20
  • Fiber+5 of 20
  • Saturated fat−18 of 20
  • Sodium−4 of 20
  • Added sugars (estimate)−20 of 20

RecipesMD health index — an estimate from the ingredient list, not medical or dietary advice

From 9 of 12 ingredient lines (100% of the measured weight), divided into 5 servings (estimated: average of rules (1: 200 g protein foods at ~170 g per serving) and model check (8)). Not matched to nutrient data: nilla wafers, evaporated milk, cream of tartar. Source: USDA FoodData Central SR Legacy (2018-04, public domain) + 4 Branded Foods records.

Equipment

  • cutting board
  • knife
  • square baking dish
  • saucepan
  • whisk
  • glass mixing bowls
  • electric hand mixer
  • oven

What the video didn’t say

  • Exact quantity of bananas used
  • Exact quantity of vanilla wafers used
  • Cooking time for custard on the stove
  • Total preparation and baking time
  • Serving size yield

Read from the public video by gemini-3.5-flash-lite on 2026-10-21. Thumbnail and video are Michelle Cottrell’s, shown through YouTube’s official embed.